Questions from Brian Allan

[Chris Phillips]

This is a thread for questions from Brian Allan (to follow).

[Chris Phillips]

Question 1 from Brian:

Does anyone think Catherine Eddowes new one of the murders, and was witness to the planned murder of Liz Stride , could she be the one who's shout of Lispki be the reason she may have been chased by the second murder and killed ,there is a name for him? Liz Stride could in my opinion not have shouted lipski ,I believe the other eye witness to the crime described Liz Stride being choked by her own neck scarf before having her throat cut, he is the person who I personally believe chased Catherine Eddowes and involved in the second murder , the blood on the apron could have been his, she was fighting for her life? He by his own admission was at the point of murder watching? Please try to imagine this without using time lines most of the time they were guessed or made to fit? Re Mrs Caroline Maxwell 14 Dorset Street, the Mary Kelly case and the strange actions of the coroner ,Was he trying to change the time line.

[Chris Phillips]

Question 2 from Brian:

Did Wynne Baxter on the 16.3.1889 and if he did who was the recipient? Was Wynne Baxter made coroner to the East end of London on 13.12.1886 . Was Wynne Baxter a translater and in what languages re Mirriam Angel? Annie Millet case last person to see her alive Richard Sage ? She died of natural causes on the steps of the workhouse where she lived , was this mentioned by the coroner at the inquest and was the workhouse part of a bigger complex? Did Wynne have connections to London University? Where did they find most of the torso body parts? Re Liz Jackson and the fetus floating in a jar on the Thames as the body parts where being found how random!

[Chris Phillips]

Question 3 from Brian:

Did Wynne Baxter mention in the inquest of Annie Chapman inquest that an American Dr had been trying to buy wombs from certain establishments in London, Who did Liz Stride meet in a women's meeting house dr? Did the same Dr identify her at the morgue? Did Wynne know William Gull and was Gull the president of London University which in1888 to around 1900 carried out experimental studies in science and chemistry

[Chris Phillips]

Question 4 from Brian:

Was Lipski in 1880s being used as a verb , like Burking in the cases of Burk and Hare the notorious murderers and grave robbers of Edinburgh , who is Braxton Hicks ? And who is Benardo? Does anyone know how many anatomy students lived in London 1880s?can anybody tell me if a police officer in the 1880s found a person lying in a street with their throat cut but possibly still alive would they stay with the body or chase the perpetrators? Would it be reasonable to think if the person died the police would take or arrange for the deceased to be taken to the morgue? Who was the mortician involved in the Liz Stride case?

[Kattrup]

Question 1 from Brian:

Does anyone think Catherine Eddowes new one of the murders,
No
and was witness to the planned murder of Liz Stride ,
No
could she be the one who's shout of Lispki be the reason she may have been chased by the second murder and killed ,there is a name for him?
No, the person who shouted lipski was a man
Liz Stride could in my opinion not have shouted lipski ,
correct
I believe the other eye witness to the crime described Liz Stride being choked by her own neck scarf before having her throat cut,
no, he described Stride being pushed to the ground, she cried out but not very loudly
he is the person who I personally believe chased Catherine Eddowes and involved in the second murder ,
ok
the blood on the apron could have been his, she was fighting for her life?
blood would then most likely be hers since she was fighting for life, murdered and mutilated

He by his own admission was at the point of murder watching?
do you mean the witness who fled the scene? He’s the killer now?
Please try to imagine this without using time lines most of the time they were guessed or made to fit? Re Mrs Caroline Maxwell 14 Dorset Street, the Mary Kelly case and the strange actions of the coroner ,Was he trying to change the time line.
No one knows, but the idea that the killer would deliberately murder at another time than usual just to throw off the police has very little merit, in my opinion

Hello Brian

your questions are a bit confusing, perhaps you could separate them and make it clearer what you mean.

Answers are underlined

[Kattrup]

Question 2 from Brian:

Did Wynne Baxter on the 16.3.1889 and if he did who was the recipient?
did Wynn’s Baxter what?
Was Wynne Baxter made coroner to the East end of London on 13.12.1886 .
No, I believe he was elected coroner of the eastern district of Middlesex
Was Wynne Baxter a translater and in what languages re Mirriam Angel?
I believe he translated some French articles or books to English but I don’t see how that has anything to do with Miriam Angel?
Annie Millet case last person to see her alive Richard Sage ?
I don’t know
She died of natural causes on the steps of the workhouse where she lived , was this mentioned by the coroner at the inquest and was the workhouse part of a bigger complex?
I don’t know what you mean
Did Wynne have connections to London University?
Undoubtedly
Where did they find most of the torso body parts?
The Thames I believe
Re Liz Jackson and the fetus floating in a jar on the Thames as the body parts where being found how random!
indeed, very random

Answers underlined

[Kattrup]

Question 3 from Brian:

Did Wynne Baxter mention in the inquest of Annie Chapman inquest that an American Dr had been trying to buy wombs from certain establishments in London,

no, he just mentioned an American
Who did Liz Stride meet in a women's meeting house dr?
I don’t know, which women’s meeting house do you mean?
Did the same Dr identify her at the morgue?
I don’t know
Did Wynne know William Gull
I don’t know
and was Gull the president of London University which in1888 to around 1900 carried out experimental studies in science and chemistry
Gull died 1890 so could hardly carry out experimental studies until 1900. To the best of my knowledge he was never president of London University.

Answers underlined

[Kattrup]

Question 4 from Brian:

Was Lipski in 1880s being used as a verb , like Burking in the cases of Burk and Hare the notorious murderers and grave robbers of Edinburgh ,
no, after the Lipski trial it was claimed that the name was used as an insult to Jews
who is Braxton Hicks ?
I don’t know
And who is Benardo?
do you mean Barnardo? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_John_Barnardo

Does anyone know how many anatomy students lived in London 1880s?
I don’t
can anybody tell me if a police officer in the 1880s found a person lying in a street with their throat cut but possibly still alive would they stay with the body or chase the perpetrators?
I believe police protocol dictated the officer must stay with the victim,
Would it be reasonable to think if the person died the police would take or arrange for the deceased to be taken to the morgue?
yes
Who was the mortician involved in the Liz Stride case?
I don’t know

Answers underlined

[Brian Allan]

In the Liz Stride case who shouted lipski a man or a woman? Who provided this information? Was it the murderer shouting lipski or the witness?

[Kattrup]

In the Liz Stride case who shouted lipski a man or a woman?
a man
Who provided this information?
the witness, Israel Schwartz
Was it the murderer shouting lipski or the witness?
well it wasn’t the witness. It was her assailant who pushed her and, when he noticed someone watching, he shouted out Lipski. It’s unknown if he shouted it to another man, who was present (often referred to as Pipeman because he had a pipe) or to the witness Schwartz.
it’s also unknown whether the man who pushed Stride also murdered he, but many people consider it likely, since she was found dead not long after the altercation.

Answers underlined

[Brian Allan]

Does anyone know if the ripper murder victims had been photographed with particular interest in their eyes re the Michael Cane jtr series? Does anybody know if any of the men in Duffield yard was wearing an eye patch re google reasons pirates wore eye patches? Is there any jtr police reports considering alevel of organisation in the crimes pre murder re.micheal cane mini series scenario john Netley Sir William Gull ? Does anyone know if the police wore womans clothing to try and catch jtr? Does anyone know if the police wearing dresses to look for jtr was the idea of sir Arthur conan author of Sherlock Homes 1887 and physician in opthalmology?

[Brian Allan]

I'm trying to find the size and dimensions of duckfield yard, to ascertain the amount of light in the yard at the time of Liz Strides murder, in that demshutz needs a lamp to see, yet Israel schwartz was witness to a woman being thrown to the ground, ? And where was the pipe smokers position in the yard ? Another question around what time shwartz observe d a woman being thrown to the floor