Is this Hutchinson?

[Andrew Komyati]

https://kpoulin1.wordpress.com/2009/...son-at-age-40/

Yay or Nay?

[Howard Brown]

Andrew:
I think that the current consensus is that is isn't a photo of Hutchinson...

[Christer Holmgren]

https://kpoulin1.wordpress.com/2009/...son-at-age-40/

Yay or Nay?

Nay. Look at the ears and the earlobes. If anything, ears on old men are larger than ears on young men. It is the other way around here. Plus the earlobes are differently attached to the faces.

The two have some likenesses, admittedly - but the differences tell the story. And Toppy has been rather closely srutinized and mapped, with no traces of any New Zealand trips.

[Adam Went]

Take the moustache out of it and I don't think the resemblance would be as strong. The bigger question is, why New Zealand? Have I missed something?

Cheers,
Adam.

[Edward Stow]

I'm pretty certain the New Zealand guy was eliminated years ago.

[Tracy Ianson]

Isn't this Karen Tremouth site? She was before my time but from what I gather what she believed and what was truth where poles apart?

[Lynn Cates]

high class

Hello Tracy.

"from what I gather what she believed and what was truth were poles apart?"

High classed ones, I hope? (heh-heh)

Cheers.
LC

[Chris G.]

Isn't this Karen Tremouth site? She was before my time but from what I gather what she believed and what was truth where poles apart?

Hi Karen

I think you might be right that Ms Tremouth began that site --

https://kpoulin1.wordpress.com/categ...phomet/page/2/

Although Ms. Tremouth has another site, http://victorianripper.niceboard.org/. Possibly kpoulin1.wordpress.com is an earlier site that Ms. Tremouth started?*

*Indeed, I have just confirmed that Karen Poulin and Karen Tremouth are the same person.

Best regards

Chris