I can't think of a Ripper theory based on anything other than speculation.
Maybe more Facts and evidence will emerge, in my experience there is always more..
But in the mean time i think 'good' speculation based on what evidence we have is a reasonable position...I certainly...
1000 results in 0.6809 seconds.
-
I agree Kasten..In my experience these things simply take time to resolve.
I don't entirely agree that it isn't potentially important...It does two important things and I very much doubt if it was forged that the person who did it understood what he/she had done. And i will expand why my...Leave a comment:
-
Hi Karsten
As you are aware Cat also doubts the letter was written by Rev Dott. But she has turned up nothing to the contrary as yet.
At first inspection I agree that the hand writing isn't a good match apart from two register signatures. But as you observe neither of us are...Leave a comment:
-
Hi Chris
I guess i just reason that people always have a reason for action. What you are suggesting is this is purely coincidence. And for me thats not logical. If the letter is a forgery then considerable time and effort went into creating it, so considerable thought must have gone into...Leave a comment:
-
And there we have it Karsten!
AND I BEKIEVE STILL IS
MacNaughten had know clue where Kozminski was after March 1889
That is the answer to the entire mystery
AND I BELEIVE STILL IS
because MacNaughten DIDNT KNOW he didn't know what happened...Leave a comment:
-
Your simply miss understanding the problem we are trying to figure OUT!
The question is about what a potential forger would have imagined?
And.. at what time when that forger would have considered his forgery would he have considered the name TILLY? unless he was following...Leave a comment:
-
Possibly RJ...but it still strikes me as a massive coincidence if coincidence it is..
So someone went to a lot of trouble researching obscure Forum threads...which doesn't add up to £250 quids worth
Or its worth continuing with the contextual analysis, which is what I'm...Leave a comment:
-
No i'm saying that if a forger decided to connect Kozminski via Matilda using the name Tilly....Thats fairly obscure. As to my knowledge the only people who had discussed Tilly as a possible connection to Matilda (Before the letter turned up) had been Karsten and myself who had speculated that Tilly...Leave a comment:
-
Yes i totally agree. And frankly thats what strikes me about the letter.
If it was forged then why take the chance or even making the connect with 'TILLY' it doesn't make sense....Apart from a relatively obscure conversation between ourselves no one had ever made the connection Tilly...Leave a comment:
-
Hi Karsten
Just picked this up and rather late so i will respond tomorrow... As you may remember Cat likes eating 'doughnuts'..But i'm sure Tim is a wonderful fellow free of poltergeist..
In the mean time you raise a number of issues that require thought
and i've...Leave a comment:
-
Unfortunately Karsten...Cat and i had a fall out with Tim and haven't spoken to him in months...this had nothing to do with the letter...But i am not one for tital tatal (Lets say Cat did some research). Its unfortunate he went to the Daily Mail...this certainly had nothing to do with me, they did however...Leave a comment:
-
I'm afraid I can't assist ..it had nothing to do with me..and i advised against the artist impression being released at this stage. It certainly has no science behind it.
I am however interested in assisting anyone undertaking serious research into the contextual evidence of the letter....as...Leave a comment:
-
Hi Anne..well thats the beef..the one piece of the jigsaw that doesn't add up...He died shortly after being placed in the asylum..
Frankly i believe this was a ruse created by Anderson, given the Crawford letter
And thats why dating the Crawford letter is simply of more importance...Leave a comment:
-
I'm sorry Chris...But i have no problem destighising between my personal beliefs as an amateur Ripperologist...of which i have a long and heart felt track record
And my professional opinion as a long and hardworking Television Producer
They are quiet separate things
...Leave a comment:
-
Yes regrettable...why can't people simply wait and do the research?
Yours Jeff...Leave a comment:
Leave a comment: